The comprehensive exam for the doctoral student (Ahmed Reda Muhammad) took place on the discussion hall at the College of Education in Al-Badanaba and Sports Sciences at the University of Karbala. The discussion committee consisted of:
Prof. Dr. Nabil Abdel Kadhim Azab / University of Babylon / President
Prof. Dr. Ahmed Mortada Abdel Hussein / University of Karbala / Member
Prof. Dr. Hussein Makki Mahmoud/ Karbala University/ Member
Prof. Dr. Ali Badawi Tabor / University of Al-Qadisiyah / Member
Prof. Dr. Khaled Muhammad Reda/ University of Karbala/ Member